My kids, ages 3 and 4, have gone through a fair share of bath toys. When looking for bath toys, I try to avoid any ones where mold may grow easily. I stay away from any squirter toys or toys with holes. If I find any toys that can easily be thrown in the dishwasher to clean, that is a win in my book!
Munchkin Boats - Simple floating boats that can be used for a wide age range of kids. These can be thrown in the dishwasher to clean off any soap grime.
Fisher-Price Little People - Not typically a bath toy but my preschoolers really like playing pretend games with these in the bathtub and I love how they don't have any way of getting water stuck in them.
Boon Jellies - These suction cup jellyfish are not only neat to look at, but fun to stick around the tub.
B. Toys Bath Toy Set - This set is so fun and makes a great gift! I love the different parts all in one- stacking cups, a fishing pole with fish, and the boat and captain for pretend play.
Suction Cup Spinner Toys - These spinners are so entertaining for a baby and can be used in multiple places, not just the bath. They are great for putting on car windows, airplane windows or on a high chair.
Munchkin Bath Letters and Numbers- Great for baby's first bath toys because they are soft and light but also great for an older child learning his letters.
Foam Car and Roads - My three-year-old has a blast with these. More on the expensive side for a bath toy but it has been worth it for the endless play it provides.
Skip Hop Buckets - Simple, open-ended play and easy to clean.
Ubbi Bath Toy Organizer - I had to include this for organizing all the toys because it is a favorite find of mine. We have tried the suction cup organizers and they always fall. I love this one because it's easy to scoop up all the toys (even the kids have fun cleaning them up) and I love how the water drains out. It's also easy to stick in the dishwasher to clean off any soap grime.